Article by

Picture of Elisha
Elisha

Other Topics

Market Insights

Market Update

Published July 8, 2021
5 mins read

Article by Elisha

There’s been much talk about the upcoming GBTC share unlocks which begin in earnest next week (Chart 1). We’ve discussed Grayscale and GBTC previously but would like to go into greater detail in the second part of this note.

Chart 1

GBTC is still primarily a retail vehicle, where the known public institutional holders account for 12.21% of the total outstanding shares – of which 3AC is the largest shareholder at 5.62%, holding a very auspicious 38,888,888 shares (Chart 2).

Chart 2 

The upcoming unlocks are for institutional holders who subscribed directly to GBTC 6 months ago – and this batch consists of all the new Q1/2021 positions, largely ARK’s last tranche (Chart 3).

Chart 3

To state clearly – We dont expect these unlocks on its own to have significant impact on the overall market outside of GBTC itself. Most of the large institutional positions who had subscribed in-kind before have already been unlocked earlier, and they have held off selling at the current discounted price. Moreover we know a large chunk of ARK’s stake is for a variety of their current ETFs like their Next Generation Internet ETF.

The fact that the market is so focused on something like this just shows the lack of real catalysts or market moving events right now, and strengthens our conviction in our short 30/40k strangle view – which we like even more now. We expect volatility to remain under pressure until mid-late Aug and for 1m implied vol to return to the long-term 50-60% range, where we will flip to vol buyers again (Chart 4).

Chart 4 

Right now our trading plan follows the 2018 BTC Analog – where we expect a dampened trading environment from here to Aug (short vol), followed by a rally possibly on the back of the EIP-1559 mainnet implementation (long spot, long calls), and then the larger Q4 Wave 5 selloff on the Fed’s taper (sell spot, buy downside risk reversals). (Chart 5)

Chart 5 

PART II: GBTC mechanics

1. This will be the last batch of unlocks as GBTC went into discount for the first time ever in Q2 this year – meaning new interest would simply buy in the open market, as compared to the prior dynamic of subscribing in kind at par, holding it over the 6 months (previously 1 year) lockup, and then selling at the average 20-30% premium that had persisted very consistently over the prior years (Chart 6).

Chart 6 

2. It was the last unlock in late Q1 this year that drove GBTC into discount to spot price – large names like Blockfi were selling (likely in response to the launch of the Purpose Bitcoin ETF – Chart 7).

Chart 7 

3. Since then we have not seen much selling interest from large holders who have already had their shares unlocked, probably choosing to wait for GBTC to trade at a premium again. Admittedly most of them would not have expected it to persist in such a large discount for so long, having expected arbitrageurs to come in and close the NAV gap.

4. We have always maintained that with redemptions continuing to be suspended, there remains no mechanism for GBTC to go back to par and it could persist in discount for a long time.

5. Outside of that, selling/buying of GBTC in the open market would just lead to wider/narrow discounts over NAV.

6. In fact as BTC matures, and institutions get more comfortable holding physical coin, they will see little reason to pay Grayscale the very steep 2% annual management fees. Furthermore in the unlikely event a BTC ETF is approved in the US it would mean the death keel for GBTC in its current closed-end fund/trust structure.

7. GBTC was essentially a “long-end of the BTC curve” play, where one could subscribe with physical BTC at par value and capture the GBTC price premium after the lock-up period. A tonne of leverage was used to maximise profits on this premium of the ‘terminal forward’:

i. Borrow BTC and subscribe at par and receive GBTC in 6 months. Profit is earned if the premium over spot after 6 months is higher than the interest rate.

ii. Borrow USD to make a double spread by buying physical BTC and shorting the perpetual swaps or futures (earn 1st spread), then use the physical BTC purchased to subscribe to GBTC to earn the premium after 6 months (earn 2nd spread).

8. Besides BTC holders who subscribe with their own BTC & later choose to take profit on said BTC by selling their GBTC shares in the open market for USD; every other leverage GBTC trade would involve using the USD proceeds from selling GBTC shares at the end to buy back spot and cover the BTC short again.

9. So does this mean GBTC unlocks are bullish spot? Initially yes – and with the persistent premium over NAV before it led to a positive bullish cycle for BTC whereby Grayscale without redemptions holds onto all the BTC subscribed with them, while institutions doing this trade had to keep buying spot after selling their GBTC shares for USD.

11. However this bullish cycle was contingent on the premiums persisting – which would attract new in-kind subscriptions, 6 months lock-up, sell GBTC shares buy back spot, rinse & repeat.

12. In a discount phase however, it means not only no new subscriptions, but those who are interested in owning BTC can buy GBTC at discount in the open market – which negates any bullish new capital impact on spot.

13. Which is essentially why backwardation is negative in the BTC near-end forward market, and why we dont expect a bull cycle to return until either an ETF is approved or GBTC goes back into premium.

14. So what can Grayscale do to get GBTC back into premium? An immediate move would be returning capital to shareholders through share buybacks, and they have already been doing so this year – having bought roughly $200m worth, with up to $750m authorised by DCG using Grayscale’s cash on hand.

15. Converting to an ETF would be the most obvious future solution, but thats entirely out of their hands, and into the still-skeptical hands of the SEC. An ETF structure with more frequent & accessible subscription/redemptions would certainly result in their share price trading much closer to par.

16. However, the flip-side to that is Grayscale themselves will be forgoing the very juicy 2% management fees they currently collect – which at the current AUM of $22bn from 651k BTC amounts to a cool $440m a year. Also with an ETF – crypto institutions who have for years been profiting off these risk-free arbitrages would have to kiss them goodbye for good, although in the current discount regime these holders would no doubt be happy to get out at par.

17. A lot of the lending desks paying high borrow rates have been using arbitrage strategies such as this GBTC premium arb as their base, and we would expect to see lending rates come down as a whole, and the attractiveness of the crypto space as a high base yield asset class lose its shine.
(incidentally a key reason why we are so focused on the options market which will continue to offer extremely attractive 100+% annualized yields, even as yields everywhere else normalize to single digits as we are seeing now)

18. Of course, if the discount gets steeper then a possible syndicated takeover offer could come – but in the event of this we expect a very negative BTC price reaction. Don’t forget GBTC is by far the largest public holders of BTC – 651k now which is a mile more than the next largest holders (Chart 8).

Chart 8 

19. Restarting redemptions would certainly close the discount to NAV – but the cost to BTC price itself would be great, and any buyer looking to takeover would also no doubt be cognisant of that. Liquidating such a massive pool of BTC will always be the challenge for them, and any sign of selling from GBTC would crash the BTC market in the near-term. As a result thus far they have only been selling amounts necessary to cover fees and miscellaneous expenses – just 5k BTC from the peak of 656k holdings since Feb (Chart 9).

Chart 9 

20. In the meantime, with funding costs low it enables holders of GBTC shares to wait out the return to premium rather than cutting loss here. Going forward, we expect GBTC par-to-spot level to be a ceiling with new subscriptions remaining close to zero.

Latest Articles

Asia Color -

09 Dec 24

December 9, 2024
1 mins read

Asia Color -

05 Dec 24

a) For the front-end traders, they were frantically covering their short positions as the continued rally squeezed into their shorts b) Mid-tenor traders were relatively

December 5, 2024
1 mins read

Asia Color -

04 Dec 24

Reject modernity, embrace tradition. These 4 four words would have served you well in navigating (and profiting!) from crypto markets in the past week. Seasoned

December 4, 2024
1 mins read

Asia Color -

03 Dec 24

December 3, 2024
1 mins read

Asia Color -

02 Dec 24

BTC briefly touched 98k over the Thanksgiving weekend, driven by Saylor’s BTC investment strategy presentation to Microsoft. Microsoft’s shareholders are scheduled to vote on a

December 2, 2024
1 mins read

Asia Color -

28 Nov 24

BTC reclaimed the critical 95,000 level last night after PCE price index came in as expected. ETH was the main outperformer yesterday as it rallied

November 28, 2024
1 mins read

Exclusive insights tailored specifically for you.

Follow us to receive the latest developments in crypto derivatives.

Disclaimer

This information contained in this website is intended as a general introduction to QCP Capital and its activities as a Digital Payment Token (DPT) service provider and is for informational purposes only.

 

QCP Capital is not acting and does not purport to act in any way as an advisor or in a fiduciary capacity vis-a-vis any counterparty. Therefore, it is strongly suggested that any prospective counterparty obtain independent advice in relation to any trading investment, financial, legal, tax, accounting or regulatory issues discussed herein. This website is only directed at informed and qualified investors. Your entry to this website attests that you are fully aware that trading of DPTs is not suitable for the general public and that you are an informed and qualified investor, and are also fully cognisant of all technological and financial risk(s) associated with trading Digital Payment Tokens.

 

In the event you intend to onboard with QCP Capital to trade in DPTs, by onboarding with us you acknowledge that you are aware of any rules and/or regulations applicable to the provision of DPT and/or financial services, the high degree of risk involved and that in no event will QCP Capital or any if its directors or employees be liable for any injury loss, claim or damage (whether direct, indirect, consequential or incidental) arising either directly or indirectly out of, or in any way connected with, the site, or its use.

 

If you are located, incorporated, or otherwise established in, or a citizen or resident of certain jurisdictions, QCP Capital may be unable to, or otherwise reserve its right to refuse to engage in or establish a trading relationship with you. Please contact us if you believe you have received this notice in error. QCP Capital is not registered or licensed to operate in the states of Louisiana and New York and will not be able to establish a trading relationship with you if you are resident, incorporated or have your principal place of business in New York or Louisiana.

 

You also acknowledge that you understand that trading in payment token derivatives (“PTD”) are also not any less risky than trading in DPTs. PTD services are not regulated by the MAS and QCP Capital is as such not licensed under the MAS to provide PTD services. You should only trade in PTDs if you are an Accredited Investor and/or have sufficient experience and knowledge in trading PTDs.

 

Risk Warning on Digital Payment Digital Services
The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) requires us to provide this risk warning to you as a customer of a digital payment token (DPT) service provider.

 

Before you pay your DPT service provider any money or DPT, you should be aware of the following.

 

Your DPT service provider is an exempt payment services provider pending licensing under the Payment Services Act (2019) to provide DPT services. Please note that this does not mean you will be able to recover all the money or DPTs you paid to your DPT service provider if your DPT service provider’s business fails.

 

You should not transact in the DPT if you are not familiar with this DPT. This includes how the DPT is created, and how the DPT you intend to transact is transferred or held by your DPT service provider.

 

You should be aware that the value of DPTs may fluctuate greatly. You should buy DPTs only if you are prepared to accept the risk of losing all of the money you put into such tokens.

 

You should be aware that your DPT service provider, as part of its licence to provide DPT services, may offer services related to DPTs which are promoted as having a stable value, commonly known as “stablecoin”.